Can a soldier receive credit on their annual evaluation for items shown on a DA 1059, such as the commandant's list for ALC?

The correct response to this question is that a soldier cannot receive credit on their annual evaluation for items shown on a DA 1059, such as being on the commandant's list for the Advanced Leader Course (ALC). The reason for this is that while a DA 1059 serves as a record of formal training and accomplishments, it does not directly translate into evaluation credit for the purposes of annual performance evaluations.

Annual evaluations are based on specific criteria and accomplishments that occur within a defined evaluation period, focusing on a soldier's performance in their assigned duties and responsibilities. Any accolades or recognitions noted on a DA 1059, including honors like the commandant's list, are typically not factored into the annual evaluation score unless they are expressly linked to a soldier's job performance during the evaluated period.

While some evaluations may consider other types of achievements or accolades, those related to formal training outside the direct purview of a soldier’s regular duties do not contribute to their evaluation credit. This helps maintain a clear distinction between formal training achievements and day-to-day performance assessments in a soldier’s career.